80 Best Amish Recipes (2024)

Home » Recipes » 80 Best Amish Recipes

Published: by Stephy 6 Comments This post may contain affiliate links. · As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Looking for old-fashioned, authentic Amish recipes? There are nearly a hundred Amish food recipes for breakfast, lunch, dinner, and desserts here.

80 Best Amish Recipes (1)

The Amish are well-known for their simple yet delicious home cooking. Amish dishes are mostly made of basic ingredients like flour and sugar, but they’re packed full of homemade flavors. From homemade dumplings and friendship bread to delicious from-scratch desserts like shoofly pie and Amish sugar cookies, there are plenty of old-fashioned foods that you can make on a budget.

Whether you are looking for Pennsylvania Dutch meals or traditional Mennonite meals, there are plenty of classic Amish food ideas to choose from. These recipes have been passed down through generations, and they’re sure to bring a taste of simplicity and cozy, home-cooked comfort meals to your table.

Get ready to experience some true Amish cooking and indulge in the wholesome goodness of a simple homemade meal. Bon appétit!

Jump to:
  • Main Dish Amish Recipes
  • Bread Recipes
  • Side Dishes
  • Dessert Recipes
  • Other Amish Recipes
  • Breakfast
  • More Frugal Recipes

Main Dish Amish Recipes


80 Best Amish Recipes (2)
  1. Amish Chicken from Just A Pinch
  2. Homemade Chicken and Noodles from NeighborFood
  3. Baked Fried Chicken from Food.com
  4. Chicken and Dumpling Casserole from Just A Pinch
  5. Chicken and Waffles from Good Food Stories
  6. Chicken Pot Pie Stew from Amish Family Recipes
  7. Chicken Casserole from Mandy’s Recipe Box
  8. Chicken Corn Soup with Rivels from Hymns and Verses
  9. Chicken Croquettes from Amish Heritage
  10. Skillet Chicken Casserole from Restless Chipotle


    80 Best Amish Recipes (3)
  11. Country Poor Man’s Hamburger Steaks from Sweet Little Bird
  12. Country Casserole from With A Blast
  13. The Best Amish Meatloaf from Food.com
  14. One Pan Ground Beef and Cabbage Skillet from Smile Sandwich
  15. Yumasetti Casserole from Tastes of Lizzy T
  16. Ground Beef and Noodle Casserole from Jam Hands
  17. Absolutely the Best Beef Stew from Food.com
  18. Amish Casserole from Allrecipes
  19. Cabbage Patch Stew from Food.com
  20. Pot Roast from Amanda’s Cookin’
  21. Amish Chili from Two Pink Peonies
  22. Country Casserole from With a Blast
  23. Homemade Friendship Soup from Recipe Lion

    Other Main Dish Amish Recipes

    80 Best Amish Recipes (4)
  24. Egg Noodles from Buns In My Oven
  25. Pea Salad with Ham and Cheese from My Baking Addiction
  26. Sausage Stuffed Green Peppers from The Seasoned Mom
  27. Roast Turkey (or Chicken) and Dressing Casserole from Wildflower’s Chicken
  28. Ham & Noodle Stove Top Casserole, Pennsylvania Dutch Style from Food.com
  29. Church Soup from Recipe Lion
  30. Golden Stew from This Mom Cooks
  31. Bridled Noodles from Can’t Stay Out of the Kitchen
  32. Sausage Soup from Little Prarie Baby
  33. Ham Loaf from Renees Kitchen Adventures

    Bread Recipes

    80 Best Amish Recipes (5)
  34. White Bread from Scratch this with Sandy
  35. Dinner Rolls from i heart eating
  36. Mennonite Yeast Rolls from The Fewell Homestead
  37. Amish Buttermilk Biscuits from Tastes of Lizzy T
  38. Grandma’s Bread from Food.com
  39. Sour Cream Corn Bread from Sweet Blue Bird
  40. Potato Rolls from My Kitchen Escapades

    Side Dishes

    80 Best Amish Recipes (6)
  41. Corn Fritters from Just A Pinch
  42. Amish Macaroni Salad from Sweet Little Bird
  43. Amish Broccoli Salad from Amish 365
  44. Broccoli Cauliflower Salad from Just A Pinch
  45. Slaw from Allrecipes
  46. Potato Stuffing from Brooklyn Farm Girl
  47. Mashed Potatoes from The Cagle Diaries
  48. Onion Fritters from The Southern Lady Cooks
  49. Pepper Cabbage Recipe from Bunny’s Warm Oven
  50. Pennsylvania Dutch Pickled Beets and Eggs from Allrecipes
  51. Baked Corn Pudding from Spinach Tiger
  52. Pasta Salad from The Southern Lady Cooks
  53. Mennonite Scalloped Potatoes with Farmer Sausage from Menno Neechie Kitchen

    Dessert Recipes

    Pies, Cookies, and Other Desserts 80 Best Amish Recipes (7)

  54. Peanut Butter Cream Pie from The Baking ChocolaTess
  55. Homemade Butterscotch Cream Pie from Amish 365
  56. Buttermilk Pie from Tastes of Lizzy T
  57. Authentic Shoo Fly Pie from Food.com
  58. Strawberry Pie from I Am Homesteader
  59. Peanut Butter Pie from Nutmeg Nanny
  60. Amish Sugar Cookies from Something Swanky
  61. Soft Sugar Cookies from Cookies and Cups
  62. Apple Fry Pies from NeighborFood
  63. Carrot Cake Friendship Bread Cupcakes with Cream Cheese Frosting from Friendship Bread Kitchen
  64. Easy Lemon Bars from Graceful Little Honey Bee
  65. Sour Cream Apple Pie from Food.com
  66. Apple Dumplings from Tastes of Lizzy T
  67. Custard Pie from Just A Pinch Recipes
  68. Apple Sponge Pudding from TIMBER TO TABLE
  69. Apple Fritters from The Grateful Girl Cooks
  70. Peach Upside Down Cake from Amish 365
  71. Baked Custard from Reffors
  72. Sand Tarts from Spinach Tiger
  73. Raisin Cookies from Taste of Home

    Bakery Desserts

    80 Best Amish Recipes (8)
  74. Amazing Cinnamon Bread from Redfly Creations
  75. Moist Banana Bread from My Patchwork Quilt
  76. Amish Friendship Bread Alternative {without a starter} from Eat Cake for Dinner
  77. Cinnamon Muffins from The Semi Sweet Sisters
  78. Cinnamon Rolls with Caramel Frosting from your home-based mom
  79. Pumpkin Cinnamon Rolls from Recipe Girl
  80. Light-As-A-Feather Doughnuts from Recipe Lion
  81. Bread Pudding from Just A Pinch

    Other Amish Recipes

    80 Best Amish Recipes (9)
  82. Homemade Pretzels from This Week for Dinner
  83. Amish Caramel Corn from Bunny’s Warm Oven
  84. Peanut Butter from Serving Up Southern
  85. Pennsylvania Dutch Pickled Eggs from Hymns and Verse
  86. Hot Bacon Dressing from Bunny’s Warm Oven
  87. Amish Church Spread from Mrfood.com


    80 Best Amish Recipes (10)
  88. Amish Breakfast Casserole from CenterCutCook
  89. Egg Bake from Grandparents Plus
  90. Mennonite Waffles and White Sauce from Mommy Moment
  91. Baked Apple and Cinnamon Oatmeal from Mel’s Kitchen Cafe
  92. Breakfast Casserole from Olivia’s Thyme
  93. Sausage Gravy from Amish Heritage
  94. Mennonite Scrambled Eggs from Food.com
  95. Baked Oatmeal from Allrecipes

More Frugal Recipes

  • 150 Super Cheap Meals for When You Are Flat Broke
  • 100 Best Old Fashioned Recipes
  • 50 Best Old Fashioned Desserts
  • 50 Frugal 1930’s Recipes That Your Grandma Made

Follow me on Pinterest, Facebook, or Instagram for more inspiration on crafts, DIY, free printables, and recipes!

80 Best Amish Recipes (2024)


What is the most popular Amish food? ›

These are some of the classics you simply must try while visiting this part of the world:
  • Butter Noodles. The Amish love of carbohydrates includes noodles as a staple accompaniment to many meals. ...
  • Breakfast Casserole. ...
  • Shoofly Pie. ...
  • Dutch Cabbage Rolls. ...
  • Pickled Beets. ...
  • Chicken Corn Soup. ...
  • Pot Pies. ...
  • Bologna.

What is a traditional Amish dish? ›

Traditional Amish food includes dishes like tasty roasted chicken, creamy mashed potatoes & gravy, seasoned vegetables, fresh bread, and homemade jam. The Amish are also known for excellent baked goods, especially pies, cookies, breads, cakes, and fry pies.

What is an Amish lunch? ›

A typical lunch might include a sandwich, fruit, celery, and milk. During the colder winter months, the schoolteacher might use the stove in the schoolhouse to heat up hot items for the children to eat at lunch.

Why do Amish cook so good? ›

The Amish cook their dishes on a wood-burning stove or over an open fire. This cooking method brings out the natural flavors in all ingredients. Additionally, the cooks use cast iron pots and pans. These pots and pans retain heat better, giving their dishes that classic, home-cooked flavor everyone loves.

Can Amish eat bacon? ›

The Amish Have No Dietary Restrictions

Having no dietary restrictions means they can eat whatever their heart desires. While many Amish stick to a traditional Pennsylvania Dutch diet, we've seen Amish dine at Olive Garden and take their buggies through the Burger King drive thru line.

What snacks do Amish eat? ›

Food is one of the methods of celebration among the Amish. Sharing a meal or a snack is a great way to fellowship. Drop in to visit an Amish family and they'll quickly invite you to share some popcorn and ice cream. It might be pretzels or chips.

What is a typical Amish breakfast? ›

In fact, they eat lots of things in soup form—even breakfast! A typical Amish breakfast includes coffee soup, a bowl of creamed coffee served with freshly baked bread for dunking.

Do Amish eat cheese? ›

Dairy is also an integral part of the Amish diet, with items like milk and cheese being common. Homegrown produce is often a staple and features vegetables such as corn, beets, peas, and more.

Do the Amish drink coffee? ›

Conclusion. So the Amish do indeed drink coffee, and it's an important part of their culture. Coffee is as Amish as horse and buggies and wicker basket weaving.

Do Amish eat healthy? ›

Distinct from American diets, Amish diets are sometimes considered “healthier” but not always. On the one hand, compared to common American diets, the Amish diet includes more home grown fruits and vegetables (Gillum et al.

Are the Amish honest people? ›

Values. The Amish are honest and ethical in everything they do, even in the smallest business transactions.

What do Amish people eat for breakfast? ›

Moist breads, heartwarming casseroles, sweet bakes, and more delicious goodies fill the Amish breakfast table. So we rounded up 13 of our favorites, from Amish Friendship Bread to Herman Biscuits to Mennonite Fritters, to showcase the sweet, tangy, and savory recipes our home cooks love.

What do Amish like to drink? ›

Many Amish people enjoy beer or wine at feasts or even at home, and some even produce their beers. It's a part of their Germanic heritage and as such is seen as part of their culture. Therefore, it's not unusual for Amish men to turn one of their barns into a space for creating community craft beers.

What time do the Amish eat dinner? ›

Rachel: Yes, nine times out of ten we sit down for a family dinner. We usually eat around 6:00–7:00 p.m., do dishes, and do something fun with the kids, and sometimes Daddy has office work. Liz: What does your family enjoy doing together?

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Tyson Zemlak

Last Updated:

Views: 5571

Rating: 4.2 / 5 (43 voted)

Reviews: 90% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Tyson Zemlak

Birthday: 1992-03-17

Address: Apt. 662 96191 Quigley Dam, Kubview, MA 42013

Phone: +441678032891

Job: Community-Services Orchestrator

Hobby: Coffee roasting, Calligraphy, Metalworking, Fashion, Vehicle restoration, Shopping, Photography

Introduction: My name is Tyson Zemlak, I am a excited, light, sparkling, super, open, fair, magnificent person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.